Back to the JournalProperty managers

How to choose a property manager in Canada: 12 questions to ask before you sign

Liliana · 7 min read ·

A good property manager is worth the fee for an owner who wants a hands-off rental. A poor one costs you more than the fee. The difference usually shows up in the contract and in a few direct questions, so ask them before you sign rather than after the first bad month.

We self-manage 19 doors, and we have no quarrel with managers. This is the list we would use if we were hiring one. For what managers typically charge and how that compares with doing it yourself, see our comparison post.

First, decide what you are buying

Managers sell different packages. Some only find and screen a tenant. Some collect rent and handle the day-to-day. Some do everything including repairs and inspections. Write down which of these you want before you take a single call, because it changes every quote you receive.

Twelve questions

Ask all twelve, and write down the answers so you can compare managers side by side.

  • Scope. Exactly what is included in the monthly fee, and what is billed separately?
  • Fees. What are the management fee, the leasing fee, any renewal fee, any setup fee and any markup on repairs?
  • Licensing. Are they licensed where the property is, and can you check the licence with the provincial regulator? Rules differ by province.
  • Client money. Where is rent held, and is it kept in a trust account separate from their own money?
  • Screening. What is their screening process, and will you see the applicant file before a tenant is chosen?
  • Repairs. What can they approve without asking you, and what is the dollar limit?
  • Vendors. Do they use their own contractors, and are there any markups or relationships you should know about?
  • Reporting. What do you receive each month, and by what date? Will you see invoices, not just totals?
  • Vacancy. How do they market an empty unit, and how fast do they usually fill one?
  • Communication. How quickly do they reply to you and to tenants, and who is the actual person you will deal with?
  • Records. Who holds the lease, the tenant files and the financial records, and can you have a copy at any time?
  • Leaving. How long is the contract, what does it cost to end it, and what happens to the tenants, the records and the deposits when you do?

Answers that should worry you

A few responses are enough to walk away.

  • They cannot tell you where rent is held.
  • Statements arrive late or as a single total with no invoices.
  • A long, hard-to-end contract with penalties that grow the longer you stay.
  • Repair costs with no invoice, or a contractor with no name.
  • They discourage you from talking to your own tenants or seeing your own books.

Interview two or three, and check references

Talk to at least two or three managers and ask each for references from owners with a similar portfolio. Ask those owners whether the monthly statements arrive on time and whether a repair ever surprised them.

Whichever manager you pick, insist on seeing your own numbers every month. Some managers work in shared software so the owner and the manager look at the same books. If you ever decide to run the doors yourself instead, that is the kind of setup we built LuxOasisOS for.

Put it into practice

Keep your rentals and your books in one place.

Start with the free 19-Door Ledger, or see how LuxOasisOS runs viewings, applications, maintenance and CRA-ready bookkeeping for a flat monthly price.

General information for Canadian landlords, not legal or financial advice. Licensing and trust-account rules differ by province. Confirm the requirements where your property is located.

Back to the Journal